Your next customer may never search for your brand. But their AI assistant will.
If your brand disappeared from Google’s search results tomorrow, you’d know almost immediately.
But if AI stopped recommending your products, would you know?
For decades, marketers have competed for consumer attention through search, paid media, retail placements, and increasingly sophisticated audience targeting. The objective was straightforward: put the right brand in front of the right consumer at the right moment.
Now, a new intermediary is entering that relationship. Consumers are increasingly asking AI to research products, compare alternatives, evaluate value, and recommend what to buy. In some cases, they’re allowing AI to complete the purchase itself. This changes how purchase decisions are made.
For ecommerce brands, the next competitive advantage is whether AI understands your products, recommends them, and helps consumers choose them.
AI shopping is already changing consumer behavior.
McKinsey’s October 2026 research, based on approximately 21,000 consumers across 11 markets, found that 53% of consumers surveyed had used AI for shopping within the previous three months. In the United States, that figure was 48%. Among U.S. AI users, the proportion who completed a purchase with AI increased from 10% to 17% year over year, a 70% relative increase.
AI also influences decisions well before checkout. McKinsey found that AI shoppers were 3.2 times more likely to identify AI search as their biggest purchase influence than traditional search. And 81% said AI was effective at narrowing and filtering their options.
That last finding is the most consequential for marketers. Consumers are using AI to consider fewer products. For brands, that means the battle for visibility is becoming a battle for inclusion in the recommendation set.
Retailers are moving quickly. Brands risk falling behind.
Amazon, Walmart, Shopify, and other commerce platforms are investing in AI-powered shopping experiences designed to make product discovery, comparison, and purchasing easier. Amazon’s Alexa for Shopping can help consumers monitor pricing, evaluate products, and act on purchasing preferences. Shopify is investing in structured product information that allows AI systems to access more accurate product attributes, pricing, and inventory.
These developments are significant because they move AI beyond generating answers and toward enabling transactions. According to Kearney research reported by EMARKETER, five of six digital retail platforms evaluated had live agentic commerce offerings, compared with just two of 53 consumer products companies. The gap highlights an emerging imbalance. Retailers are building infrastructure to influence how AI shops. Many brands are still focused on improving how frequently they appear in AI-generated answers.
Both matter. But visibility alone doesn’t create a competitive advantage if consumers can’t confidently evaluate or purchase the product being recommended. As AI shopping develops, brands will need to compete across the entire journey, from discoverability and consideration to conversion.
What is agentic commerce, and why does it matter for ecommerce marketing?
Agentic commerce refers to the use of AI systems to assist with or execute shopping activities on behalf of consumers, including researching products, comparing alternatives, evaluating prices, and completing purchases.
Unlike traditional ecommerce search, which often presents consumers with a broad selection of products to evaluate themselves, AI-powered shopping can narrow choices based on individual needs and preferences. Consider a consumer looking for a premium skincare product. Traditional search might lead them through sponsored listings, retailer websites, reviews, influencer content, and multiple product pages.
An AI assistant might instead evaluate product ingredients, skin sensitivities, consumer reviews, pricing, availability, and brand credibility before presenting three recommendations. For the brands included, that’s a valuable opportunity. For the brands excluded, it’s lost consideration before a website visit ever occurs.
This creates a new challenge for marketers: How do you influence a consumer decision when technology increasingly determines which options the consumer sees?
From share of voice to share of recommendation
Traditional marketing has relied on familiar indicators of competitive presence: share of voice, share of search, impression share, website traffic, and conversion rates. Those measures remain important. But they don’t fully explain how a brand performs when consumers use AI to evaluate purchase options.
Brands now need to understand their share of recommendation: how frequently they appear among AI-generated recommendations for relevant consumer needs, how they compare with competitors, and whether their inclusion translates into meaningful business outcomes. Share of recommendation is an emerging analytical concept, not a standardized industry metric. It requires consistent prompts, platforms, audience scenarios, and measurement methodologies. For ecommerce brands, this creates three distinct but connected objectives:
Be discoverable. Ensure AI systems can access and accurately interpret relevant product information, brand attributes, and credible third-party signals.
Be recommended. Understand which consumer needs, product characteristics, and competitive considerations influence whether a brand appears among relevant options.
Be chosen. Connect visibility and consideration to actual consumer behavior, including qualified traffic, conversion, customer acquisition, and revenue.
Winning requires all three.
Why product information and brand authority matter in AI shopping
AI-powered shopping depends on information. Product specifications, pricing, inventory, shipping options, return policies, customer reviews, and third-party validation can all contribute to how AI systems evaluate products. McKinsey reports that Shopify has observed roughly twice the conversion rate when AI searches access its structured product catalog compared with searches relying on scraped or outdated information. That’s an important signal, though it’s a platform-reported observation, not a universal performance benchmark. It suggests the quality and accessibility of product information increasingly shape ecommerce performance.
Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) focuses on improving how brands and their information are understood, retrieved, and represented within AI-powered discovery environments. For ecommerce marketers, that means going beyond traditional keyword optimization to consider product data, content relevance, third-party authority, brand differentiation, and the accuracy of information available to AI systems. But GEO shouldn’t operate in isolation. It must connect to the broader marketing programs that build awareness, influence preference, and convert demand.
Paid media remains important, but its role is changing.
The rise of agentic commerce has prompted questions about the future of advertising. If AI increasingly recommends products directly, what happens to paid search? What happens to retail media? And how should marketers think about investment across traditional and emerging channels? The answer is unlikely to be a wholesale replacement of existing media.
Google is exploring how advertising and commercial opportunities can function within AI-powered shopping experiences. Retailers also have strong incentives to preserve advertising revenue while improving consumer discovery and purchasing experiences. Meanwhile, consumers will continue to form preferences based on brand familiarity, perceived value, trust, product quality, and experience. Media remains an important mechanism for shaping those preferences. The opportunity for marketers is to connect brand-building activity, performance media, retail media, and AI discoverability rather than treating them as competing priorities.
“AI is changing who makes the shortlist. What makes a brand worth choosing hasn’t changed. Brands that connect strong consumer insight, credible product information, and precise media investment will win. Marketers need to build the preference that makes an AI recommendation meaningful and measurable.”
-Gina Whelehan, Group Director, Strategy & Partnerships, Butler/Till
This is the next evolution of integrated media strategy. The objective is to understand how consumer behavior is changing, identify where media can create incremental value, and invest with greater precision rather than chase every emerging AI advertising opportunity.
How can ecommerce brands improve visibility in AI shopping recommendations?
There’s no single tactic that guarantees a brand will appear in AI-generated recommendations. However, ecommerce marketers can take practical steps to strengthen discoverability, improve the information supporting consideration, and evaluate how AI influences business outcomes.
1. Establish an AI discoverability baseline.
Understand how your brand and products appear across major AI discovery environments, including ChatGPT, Google AI experiences, and relevant retailer shopping assistants. Evaluate performance across high-intent consumer questions, product categories, competitive comparisons, and purchase scenarios. The objective is to identify where the brand is visible, where competitors are being recommended, and where information gaps may exist.
2. Strengthen the information behind the recommendation.
Review the accuracy, accessibility, and consistency of product information across owned websites, retailer environments, product feeds, and relevant third-party sources. Ensure AI systems can interpret product benefits, specifications, pricing, availability, and meaningful differentiation. This requires coordination across marketing, ecommerce, merchandising, and technology teams.
3. Connect GEO to paid media and brand strategy.
Use discoverability insights alongside audience intelligence and existing media performance to identify opportunities to build demand and influence consideration. Rather than treating GEO as a standalone optimization exercise, connect it to paid search, paid social, retail media, content, and brand-building investments.
4. Measure business outcomes, not just AI mentions.
Track recommendation frequency and competitive visibility, but connect those indicators to downstream performance wherever measurement is possible. That includes qualified traffic, conversion rates, customer acquisition costs, incremental revenue, and return on media investment. As AI-mediated shopping grows, brands will also need to account for journeys in which consumers interact with AI before arriving at a retailer or brand website.
5. Test, learn, and adapt.
Consumer adoption, platform capabilities, and advertising opportunities are changing rapidly. Brands should establish repeatable testing frameworks that help determine which changes improve discoverability, which media investments influence performance, and where new opportunities justify additional resources. The goal is to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the entire customer acquisition strategy.
The Butler/Till perspective: Precision for AI-era ecommerce growth
At Butler/Till, we believe AI-powered shopping is expanding the definition of media effectiveness. For ecommerce brands, success increasingly requires understanding who the customer is, where to reach them, and how their consideration set is formed. That requires connecting audience intelligence, generative search visibility, media strategy, and business measurement.
We evaluate marketing investment by its ability to influence meaningful business outcomes. For brands navigating AI-powered commerce, that means asking different questions. Where are consumers discovering our products? Which competitors are being recommended? What information is influencing those recommendations? How does existing media investment contribute to brand preference? And how do we connect these signals to acquisition and revenue? These are growth strategy questions.
Butler/Till brings an integrated perspective to that challenge, connecting the intelligence behind audience and media decisions with emerging approaches to AI discoverability and measurement. Our GEO Snapshot provides a starting point for understanding how brands appear in AI-generated responses, where competitive visibility gaps exist, and what those findings may mean for broader marketing strategy. From there, the opportunity is to connect insights to action by identifying where content, media, and measurement can work together to improve performance.
The next competitive advantage is being chosen.
AI isn’t eliminating the fundamentals of marketing. Consumers will still care about brand reputation, quality, convenience, value, and trust. Media will continue to influence those perceptions and help create demand. What’s changing is the path between consumer need and brand choice. Increasingly, AI determines which products consumers consider before they ever click an advertisement, visit a website, or enter a store.
For ecommerce marketers, that creates both a risk and an opportunity. The risk is losing visibility within a decision process that is becoming harder to observe through traditional analytics. The opportunity is to build a more connected strategy, one that strengthens discoverability, influences consideration, and measures the business impact of being chosen.
Ecommerce growth will go to brands that are discoverable, credible, relevant, and ready to convert consideration into customers. Every ecommerce CMO should be asking how their brand shows up in AI recommendations today.
Frequently asked questions
What is GEO for ecommerce?
Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) is the practice of improving how a brand and its products are understood, retrieved, and represented in AI-generated search results and shopping recommendations. For ecommerce brands, GEO involves product data, structured content, brand authority, third-party information, and ongoing visibility measurement.
How is AI changing ecommerce marketing?
Consumers increasingly use AI to discover products, compare alternatives, narrow their consideration sets, and make purchases. This requires ecommerce marketers to evaluate how AI influences product visibility, brand consideration, customer acquisition, and conversion alongside traditional search and media channels.
Will agentic commerce replace paid search and retail media?
Agentic commerce is unlikely to eliminate paid media. Instead, it’s creating new discovery environments and potential advertising opportunities. Ecommerce brands will need to connect traditional paid media, retail media, brand building, and AI discoverability within a coordinated growth strategy.
How should ecommerce brands measure AI shopping performance?
Brands should evaluate AI recommendation visibility, competitive inclusion, referral quality, conversion, customer acquisition costs, and incremental revenue. AI visibility metrics should complement, not replace, established business performance measures.
How can Butler/Till help ecommerce brands prepare for AI-powered shopping?
Butler/Till can help brands evaluate AI discoverability, identify competitive visibility opportunities, and connect those insights to broader media strategy and measurement. Its GEO Snapshot offers a starting point for understanding how brands appear in AI-generated responses and where to optimize further.
References
- McKinsey & Company — Who wins when AI does the shopping? New evidence on agentic commerce, October 2026.
- EMARKETER — Retailers are building for AI shoppers while most brands are still fighting to be seen, October 2026.
- EMARKETER — Amazon expands AI shopping features to retain holiday shoppers amid earnings miss, October 2026.
- Forkast — Salesforce published conversion numbers for agent-native shopping search, October 2026.
- Business Insider — Google’s advertising strategy as AI agents take on shopping, October 2026.